Old Style Deli Menu

Step inside Old Style Deli at 200 S Main St in Elkhart, and you’ll immediately feel the comforting charm of a true local favorite. The Old Style Deli Menu reads like a love letter to timeless American deli classics - stacked sandwiches bursting with flavor, hearty soups that warm you from the inside out, and crisp salads made with fresh ingredients. Each bite carries that perfect balance between homestyle comfort and deli craftsmanship, whether you’re sinking your teeth into a pastrami on rye or a perfectly toasted Reuben. The menu doesn’t stop there - you’ll also find daily specials and baked goods that pair beautifully with a hot cup of coffee. It’s the kind of place where familiar flavors meet friendly faces, and every meal feels like a nostalgic return to simpler times, crafted with care and served with heart.

Hot Dogs

Tubin' Reuben
Quarter pound dog, sauerkraut, swiss, 1,000 land dressing on a deli roll
US$9.89
Lou Dog
Quarter pound dog, melted cheddar, grilled onion,horseradish on a deli roll
US$9.89
Dog With Cheese
Plain on a deli roll.
US$9.89
Walking The Dog
Quarter pound dog, pepper jack cheese,tomatoes, dill pickle, onions, ketchup & mustard
US$9.89
Dirty Dog
Quarter pound dog, melted cheddar, grilled onion, bacon ona deli rol
US$9.89
Dog
Plain on a deli roll
US$8.89

Soups On

Soups On Cup
US$3.99
Soups On Bowl
US$4.49

Ham Sandwiches

B.L.T.
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo on toast
US$9.49
Ham On The Range
Hot ham, bacon, swiss, cheddar, lettuce,tomato, dijon dressing on a sesame bun
US$10.39
Ham Me Down
ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo on three slices of toast
US$10.89
Ham Kinneson
Hot ham, swiss, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato mayo on grilled italian
US$10.39
Cling On
Ham, turkey, provolone, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato,mayo on grilled italian
US$10.39
Farmer In The Deli
Ham,turkey, swiss, cheddar, lettuce,tomato, cucumber, brown mustard, & mayo on deli roll
US$10.89

Pam's Baking

Muffin
US$2.99
Carrot Cake
US$3.99
Coffee Cake
US$3.99
Cinammon Roll
US$3.99
Cookie
US$1.49
Pecan Roll
US$3.79

Pastrami

Wyatt's Way
Hot pastrami, peperoncini, provolone, tomato, grilled onions, horseradísh sauce on a deliroll
US$10.89
V.I.P.
Hot pastrami,provolone, grilled onions, brown mustard on an onion roll
US$10.89
Conan O’brian
Hot pastrami, cheddar, grilled onion,horseradish sauce on a deli roll
US$10.89
V-V Top
Hot pastrami, provolone, grilled onion, tomato, horseradish sauce on grilled italian
US$10.89

Beverages

Apple Juice
US$2.79
Assorted Snapples
US$2.99
Stewart's Rootbeers
US$3.49
Elkhart Water
US$0.09
Raspberry Ice Tea
US$2.99
V8
US$2.79
Unsweetened Ice Tea
US$2.99
Coke
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
US$2.99
Orange Juice
US$2.79
Gatorade
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
US$2.69
Bottle Water
US$1.49

Stuff

Pickle
US$0.09
Spinach
US$0.09
Lettuce
US$0.09
Red Or White Onion
US$0.09
Cucumber
US$0.09
Tomato
US$0.09

Create Your Own Sandwich

Corned Beef
US$10.89
Chicken Salad
US$9.89
Roast Beef
US$9.89
Turkey
US$9.89
Pastrami
US$10.89
Ham
US$9.89
Egg Salad
US$9.89
Tuna Salad
US$9.89
Tuna Steak
US$11.89
Chícken Breast
US$10.39

Scramblers

The Hangover Helper
Two scrambled eggs, potatoes, mushrooms, onions, cheddar cheese, and your choice of meat inside
US$12.39
James Corden Bleu
Grilled chicken and ham with melted Swiss cheese with your choice of toast
US$11.39
Fire Sign
Two eggs scrambled, green peppers, onions, hot pepper cheese and rye toast
US$10.39
Mu-Tang Scram
Seasoned browned beef patty, two eggs, potatoes, onions, shredded cheese with your choice of toast.
US$11.89
The Greekster
Sliced Gyro meat, feta cheese, onions, tomatoes and baby spinach Grilled chicken and ham with melted Swiss cheese with your choice of toast.
US$12.39

Sauces

Ketchup
US$0.09
Mustard
US$0.09
Mayo
US$0.09
Yellow Or Brown
US$0.09
Honey Mustard
US$0.99
Rooster Ranch
US$0.99
Horseradish Sauce
US$0.09
Dijon
US$0.09
Bbq
US$0.99
Dill Dressing
US$0.99

Extras

Kraut
US$0.99
Olives
US$0.99
Slaw
US$1.99
Mushrooms
US$1.19
Avocado
US$1.69
Add Bacon For Sandwich
US$1.99

Salads

Out Of The Blue Chicken
Grilled chicken breast,craisins, walnuts, crumbled blue cheese, balsamic vinaigrette
US$11.89
Garden Salad
Mixed lettuce greens, egg cucumber peppers,tomatoes,cheese, choice of dressing:
US$7.49
Chef
Turkey or ham, bacon, tomatoes, hard boiled eg, cucumbers, peppers, shredded cheddar
US$10.89
Grilled Chicken
Grilled chicken breast, tomato, hard boiled egg,cucumbers, shredded cheddar, choice of dressing
US$10.89
Texas Chicken
Chicken tenders-fried, tomato, hard boiled egg,shredded cheddar, cucumbers, peppers, ranch dressing
US$10.89
Island Chicken
Grilled chicken breast, pineapple, almonds,monterey jack cheese, poppy seed dressing
US$10.89

Egg Salad

Eggstravagant
Egg salad, bacon, tomato, spinach on dark rye
US$9.89
Egglusive Club
Egg salad, bacon,lettuce,tomato on the three slices of wheat toast
US$10.49

Breakfast Sammies

One Egg, Choice Of Meat And Cheese On Toast.
US$9.49
Don't Go Bacon My Heart
Grilled sausage patty, bacon and ham, scrambled egg and melted Swiss cheese on a bagel.
US$9.49
One Egg, Choice Of Cheese And Toast.
US$9.28
One Egg On Toast.
US$7.89
Texas Blt
One egg, american cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo on grilled texas toast.
US$9.49
Bow Chicka-Brown-Cow
Fresh all beef patty, one fried egg, bacon, american cheese, mayo on a bagel or english muffin
US$9.49

Breads

Wheat Or White Bun
US$0.09
Sliced Italian
US$0.09
Whole Grain
US$0.09
White Onion Roll
US$0.09
Rye
US$0.09
Sesame Roll
US$0.09
Pita
US$0.99
Deli Roll
US$0.09
Dark Rye
US$0.09
Sourdough
US$0.09

Roast Beef sandwiches

Colin’s Cafe
Roast beef, turkey, cheddar, spinach, tomato, horseradish sauce on Italian
US$10.69
Philly-U-Up
Hot roast beef, cream cheese, grilled peppers, onions on an onion bun
US$10.69
Deli Dip
Hot roast beef, Monterey Jack cheese, au jus on a deli roll.
US$10.69
Jack’s Hot Cafe
Hot roast beef and turkey, cheddar, spinach, tomato, horseradish sauce on a grilled Italian.
US$10.69
David Letterman
Hot roast beef, cheddar, grilled onions, horseradish sauce on a deli roll.
US$10.69
John’s Juicy Jersey
Hot roast beef, Monterey Jack, grilled mushrooms, horseradish sauce, au jus on a deli roll.
US$10.69
Beef Me Up
Hot roast beef, provolone, grilled onions and mushrooms, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard and grilled Italian.
US$10.69

Chicken

Tender Basket
Three white meat tenders, french fries, cole slaw; choice of sauces: bbq, honey mustard, ranch, dill
US$12.89
Chick A Dilly
Grilled chicken breast, melted swiss & cheddar,tomato, lettuce, dill sauce on awholewheat bun
US$10.69
Luv Chicken
Grilled chicken breast, melted pepper jack cheese,spinach, tomato, honey mustard on an onion roll
US$10.89
Popeye Pocket
Chicken salad, spinach, almonds in a pita pocket
US$10.89
Holly's Healthy Hen
Grilled chcken breast, dijon, lettuce,tomato on a whole wheat bun
US$10.69
What The Cluck?
Chicken salad, swiss, bacon, lettuce, tomato on an onion roll
US$10.69
Frisco Chick
Grilled chicken breast, melted swiss, bacon, lettuce,tomato, ranch dressing on a wholewheat bun
US$10.69
Bailey's Never Bleu
Grilled chicken breast, ham, melted swiss,honey mústard on awholewheat bun
US$10.69
Lindsey's Luv Me Tenders
Three white meat chicken tenders; choice of sauces: bq, honey mustard, ranch
US$9.89
Crispy Chicken
Two fried chicken tenders with melted american cheese, bbq sauce on a sesame bun
US$10.69
Chicken Charlie
Chicken salad, bacon, cheddar, tomato, lettuce on an onion roll
US$10.89

Almost World Famous Baked Goods

Cinnamon Roll
US$3.99
Pecan Roll
US$3.29
Coffee Cake
US$3.99
Carrot Cake
US$3.99
Assorted Muffins
US$3.29

Cheese Please

Everleighlasting
Feta chese, spinach, tomato, red onion, dill dressing on grilled wholegrain
US$9.69
Texas
American cheese, bacon on grilled texas toast
US$9.39
Frisco
Monterey Jack cheese on grilled sour dough
US$8.49
Not Mom's
American& pepper jack cheese, avocado, bacon, honey mustard on grilled italian mustard on grilled italian
US$9.89
Mom's
American cheese on grilled white
US$8.49

Veggies Please

Joey
Shredded lettuce with swiss& cheddar, tomato, cucumbers, in a pita, with a side of dill sauce
US$10.89
Cara's Choice
Herbed cream cheese, fresh spinach, avocado,tomato, red onion, almonds on a pita
US$10.89
Randy's Tupelo Honey
Melted pepper jack cheese & cheddar,tomato, ávocado, red onion, honey mustard on grilled dark rye
US$10.69
Lydia
Herbed Cream Cheese, Tomato, Cucumber,Spinach on whole grain bread
US$9.69

Breakfast (Available until 11 am)

French Toast
Three Pieces of Texas Toast
US$8.69
Side Of Ham
US$3.49
Two Eggs. Potatoes, Choice Of Meat, Toast
Old Style Potatoes with Your Choice of Ham or Bacon or Sausage with Toast.
US$12.89
Sausage Patty
US$3.49
Two Eggs, Old Style Potatoes And Toast.
US$10.39
Pancakes.
US$9.89
Two Eggs And Toast.
Choose how you want your eggs prepared and choice of toast
US$7.89
Bacon 3 Pcs
US$3.49
Dumb Questions.
US$1.79
Two Eggs. Choice Of Meat, Toast
Choice of Ham, Bacon or Sausage W/toast.
US$10.39

Poultry Burgers

Katzenburger
Turkey burger, cheddar, green olives, tomato,lettuce, mayo on a wholewheat bun
US$10.79
Turkey Burger
Choice of condiments on a whole wheat bun
US$10.59
Turkey In The Slaw
Turkey burger, cole slaw, honey mustard on a whole wheat bun
US$10.79

Burgers

Mushroom Swiss Burger
Melted swiss,grilled mushrooms, dijonnaise on a white bun
US$10.39
J.P. Burger
Swiss&cheddar, grilled onions &mushrooms, duon,mâyo, lettuce, tomato onwholewheat bun
US$10.39
Billy Burger
Avocado, bacon, blue cheese on whole wheat bun
US$10.89
Pax's Patty Melt
American cheese, tomato, 1,000 island dressing on grilled rye
US$9.89
Cheese Burger
American cheese & choice of condiments served on a white bun
US$9.39
Burger
Choice of condiments served on a white bun
US$8.89
Philly Burger
Cream cheese, grilled peppers & onions ôn an oníon roll
US$10.39
Kate & Tessa's Beach Burger
Melted american cheese,bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo on a white bun
US$9.89

Drinks

Stewart’s Rootbeer
US$3.49
Stewart’s Cream Soda
US$3.49
V8
US$2.39
Stewart’s Orange Cream
US$3.49
Yoohoo
US$2.99
Brewed Iced Tea
US$2.99
Juice
US$2.79
Assorted Snapple’s
US$2.89
Fountain Drinks
US$2.99
Bottled Water
US$1.99

Omelettes

City With A Heart
Ham, red and green peppers, onions, mushrooms, cheddar and swiss cheese, and your choice of toast.
US$12.89
Gordon Hamsey
Bacon, ham, potatoes, american and jack cheese w/side horseradish sauce and choice of toast.
US$12.89
The Whatever
Tell us what you want in your omelette or we will decide for you.
US$12.69
The Superfly
Grilled chicken breast, onions, red and green peppers, jalapeños, cheddar and pepper jack cheese, side of salsa and sour cream with choice of toast.
US$13.69
From My Head Tomatoes
All the fresh veggies. Mushrooms, red and green peppers, red onions, tomatoes, avocado, cheddar and swiss cheese. Served with toast and side side of salsa.
US$12.89

Corned Beef

Russian Reuben
Hot corned beef, swss, coleslaw, russian dressing on grilled dark rye
US$10.89
Reuben
Hot corned beef, swiss, sauerkrajt, 1,000 sand dressing on grilled rye
US$10.89
Hayden's Corney
Hot corned beef, melted cheddar, dijonaisse,coleślaw on grilled sour dough
US$10.89

Turkey Sandwiches

Turkey Sub
Turkey, ham, pastrami, provolone, lettuce, tomato,onion, italian dressing on deli roll
US$10.89
Jimmy Fallon
Hot turkey breast, cheddar, grilled onions,horseradísh sauce on deli roll
US$10.49
Two Rich To See
Turkey breast, swiss, bacon, tomato, lettuce & mayo on rye
US$10.39
Herbin Tomboy
Hot turkey breast, herbed cream cheese,cucumbers, tomato, spinách, dijonnaise on whole grain toast
US$10.89
Turkey Club
Turkey breast, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo on three slices of toast.
US$10.69
Flip Your Dip
Turkey breast, monterey jack, on a deli roll with a side of au jus
US$10.39
Tom Terrific
Hot turkey breast, provolone, onion, spinach, tomatc, dijonaisse on grilled italian
US$10.39
Reuben Royal
Hot turkey breast, swiss, coleslaw, honey mustard on grilled rye
US$10.39

Tuna

Sister Sandwich
Tuna steak, pepper jack cheese, dill sauce,spinach, tomato, avocado, red onion on a wholewheat bun
US$11.89
Charlie's Club
Tuna salad, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayo onthree slices of toast
US$10.89
Come Tuna My Window
Tuna salad, swiss& cheddar,lettuce, tomato, red onion in a pita
US$10.89
Tuna Melt
Tuna salad, cheddar on grilled rye
US$9.89
Sorry Charlie
Tuna salad, cheddar, bacon lettuce, tomato on an onion roll
US$10.39
Webbers Down “Under The Sea"
Grilled tuna steak, avocado, grilled pineapple, pepper jack cheese, honey mustard on grilled sourdough
US$11.89

Cheeses

Plain Or Herbed
US$1.49
Feta Or Blue
US$1.49
Cream Cheese
US$1.49
Cheddar
US$1.49
American
US$1.49
Provolone
US$1.49
Swiss
US$1.49
Pepper Jack
US$1.49
Monterey Jack
US$1.49

Sides

Deli Chips
Seasoned waffle cut potatoes topped with parmesan cheese
US$5.29
French Fries
US$3.49
Onion Rings
Served with rooster ranch
US$4.99
Cauliflower Bites Ser
Served with dill dressing
US$5.79
Coleslaw
US$2.79
Sweet Potato Fries
US$4.99
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available. 📞 +1 574-295-2133